RESEARCH PROGRESS ON EVALUATION AND TEST METHOD FOR ICING ADHESION CHARACTERISTICS

Li Yan; Shen He; Guo Wenfeng; Feng Fang; Tagawa Kotaro

doi:10.19912/j.0254-0096.tynxb.2022-1469

PDF(3612 KB)

Acta Energiae Solaris Sinica ›› 2023, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (7) : 291-302. DOI: 10.19912/j.0254-0096.tynxb.2022-1469

RESEARCH PROGRESS ON EVALUATION AND TEST METHOD FOR ICING ADHESION CHARACTERISTICS

Li Yan^1,2, Shen He¹, Guo Wenfeng^1,2, Feng Fang^2,3, Tagawa Kotaro⁴

Author information +

History +

Abstract

In recent years, extreme weather has occurred frequently with global climate degradation. Natural disasters such as extreme cold and icing seriously degrade the safe and efficient operation of wind turbines. Exploring the icing mechanism and obtaining the adhesive characteristics between ice and materials is the foundation for developing cost-effective anti-icing and de-icing technologies for wind turbines. This paper reviews the theories, evaluation and testing methods of the ice adhesive characteristics, the different test methods are compared and analyzed. The contents provide a foundation of in-depth research on icing mechanisms and the development of anti- and de-icing technologies for wind turbines.

Key words

wind turbines / blades / ice / adhesion / theory / evaluation / test method

Cite this article

EndNote

Ris (Procite)

Bibtex

Download Citations

Li Yan, Shen He, Guo Wenfeng, Feng Fang, Tagawa Kotaro. RESEARCH PROGRESS ON EVALUATION AND TEST METHOD FOR ICING ADHESION CHARACTERISTICS[J]. Acta Energiae Solaris Sinica. 2023, 44(7): 291-302 https://doi.org/10.19912/j.0254-0096.tynxb.2022-1469

References

[1] 李德源, 袁茂圣, 吕文阁, 等. 大型水平轴风力机组混合多体模型研究[J]. 太阳能学报, 2013, 34(11): 2013-2019.
LI D Y, YUAN M S, LYU W G, et al.Research on the hybrid multibody system model of the large scale horizontal axis wind turbine[J]. Acta energiae solaris sinica, 2013, 34(11): 2013-2019.
[2] 田德, 方建驹, 刘枫, 等. 大型风电机组模型预测独立变桨控制器设计[J]. 太阳能学报, 2022, 43(4): 461-467.
TIAN D, FANG J J, LIU F, et al.Design of model predictive individual pitch controller for large-scale wind turbine[J]. Acta energiae solaris sinica, 2022, 43(4): 461-467.
[3] 白叶飞, 汪建文, 赵元星, 等. 风力机叶片叶根应力集中区应力状态实验研究[J]. 太阳能学报, 2017, 38(12): 3406-3411.
BAI Y F, WANG J W, ZHAO Y X, et al.Experimental study of stress state in stress concentration area of wind turbine blade root[J]. Acta energiae solaris sinica, 2017, 38(12): 3406-3411.
[4] 胡良权, 陈进格, 沈昕, 等. 风力机叶片结冰水滴收集系数计算[J]. 太阳能学报, 2020, 41(3): 22-28.
HU L Q, CHEN J G, SHEN X, et al.Calculation of water droplets collection efficiency on wind turbine blades[J]. Acta energiae solaris sinica, 2020, 41(3): 22-28.
[5] LI Y, SHEN H, GUO W F.Effect of ultrasonic vibration on the surface adhesive characteristic of iced aluminum alloy plates[J]. Applied. sciences, 2022, 12, 2357.
[6] 易贤, 王开春, 马洪林, 等. 水平轴风力机结冰及其影响计算分析[J]. 太阳能学报, 2014, 35(6): 1052-1058.
YI X, WANG K C, MA H L, et al.Computation of icing and its effect of horizontal axis wind turbine[J]. Acta energiae solaris sinica, 2014, 35(6): 1052-1058.
[7] 王绍龙. 水平轴风力机叶片结冰分布数值模拟与冰风洞试验研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 东北农业大学, 2017.
WANG S L.Numerical simulation and icing wind tunnel test study on icing distribution on blade of horizontal axis wind turbine[D]. Harbin: Northeast Agricultural University, 2017.
[8] KUMAR R N, PIZZI A.Adhesives for wood and lignocellulosic substratess[M]. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons Inc, 2019, 31-59.
[9] Fourche, G. (1995). An overview of the basic aspects of polymer adhesion. part I: fundamentals[J]. Polymer engineering and science, 1995, 35(12), 957-967.
[10] RYZHKIN I A, PETRENKO V F.Physical Mechanisms Responsible for Ice Adhesion[J]. The journal of physical chemistry B, 1997, 101: 6267-6270.
[11] MAKKONEN L.Surface melting of ice[J]. The journal of physical chemistry B, 1997, 101(32): 6196-6200.
[12] 金敬福. 材料冻粘特性及矿车冻粘规律试验研究[D]. 长春: 吉林大学, 2004.
JIN J F.Experimental research on material freezing adhesive characteristic and tramcar freezing adhesive law. Changchun: Jilin University, 2004.
[13] ZHU C X, ZHU C L, ZHAO W W, et al.Experimental study on the shear adhesion strength between the ice and substrate in icing wind tunnel[J]. Journal of mechanics, 2017, 34(2): 209-216.
[14] 巫瑞锐. 结冰力学特性的理论与实验研究[D]. 南京: 南京航空航天大学, 2014.
WU R R.Research on theories and experiments of mechanical properties of impact ice[D]. Nanjing: Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2014.
[15] 唐珊. 表面特性对冰粘结强度影响的研究[D]. 广州: 广州大学, 2014.
TANG S.Research on the effects of surface properties on ice adhesion strength[D]. Guangzhou: Guangzhou University, 2014.
[16] KULINICH S A, FARZANEH M.How wetting hysteresis influences ice adhesion strength on superhydrophobic surfaces[J]. Langmuir, 2009, 25(16): 8854-8856.
[17] DODIUK H, KENIG S, DOTAN A.Do self-cleaning surfaces repel ice?[J]. Journal of adhesion science and technology, 2012, 26(4-5): 701-714.
[18] KULINICH S A, FARHADI S, NOSE K, et al.Superhydrophobic surfaces: are they really ice-repellent?[J]. Langmuir, 2011, 27(1): 25-29.
[19] KULINICH S A, FARZANEH M.On ice-releasing properties of rough hydrophobic coatings[J]. Cold regions science and technology, 2011, 65(1): 60-64.
[20] JAFARI R, MENINI R, FARZANEH M.Superhydrophobic and icephobic surfaces prepared by RF-sputtered polytetrafluoroethylene coatings[J]. Applied surface science, 2010, 257(5): 1540-1543.
[21] ANDERSSON L O, GOLANDER C G, PERSSON S.Ice adhesion to rubber materials[J]. Journal of adhesion science and technology, 1994, 8(2): 117-132.
[22] KUMAR R N, PIZZI A.Adhesives for wood and lignocellulosic materials[M]. Beverly: John Wiley & Sons Inc, 2019: 31-59.
[23] ALANSATAN S, PAPADAKIS M.Experimental Investigation of Ice Adhesion[J]. Sae technical papers, 1999, 1: 1584.
[24] REICH A.Interface influences upon ice adhesion to airfoil materials[C]//32nd Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, USA, 1994.
[25] FERRICK M G, MULHERIN N D, COUTERMARSH B A, et al.Minimization of ice adhesion to space shuttle component surfaces[J]. Journal of adhesion science and technology, 2012, 26(4-5): 473-503.
[26] MEULER A J, SMITH J D, VARANASI K K, et al.Relationships between water wettability and ice adhesion[J]. ACS applied materials & interfaces, 2010, 2(11): 3100-3110.
[27] SAITO H, TAKAI K, YAMAUCHI G.Water-and ice-repellent coatings[J]. Surface coatings international, 1997, 80(4): 168-171.
[28] SUBRAMANYAM S B, RYKACZEWSKI K, VARANASI K K.Ice adhesion on lubricant-impregnated textured surfaces[J]. Langmuir, 2013, 29(44), 13414-13418.
[29] WEI C, JIN B, ZHANG Q, et al.Anti-icing performance of super-wetting surfaces from icing-resistance to ice-phobic aspects: robust hydrophobic or slippery surfaces[J]. Journal of alloys and compounds, 2018, 765: 721-730.
[30] 郭琦, 申晓斌, 林贵平, 等. 积冰粘附力试验及影响因素分析[J]. 飞机设计, 2019, 39(4): 33-37.
GUO Q, SHEN X B, LIN G P, et al.Experimental analysis on adhesion force between ice and substrate[J]. Aircraft design, 2019, 39(4): 33-37.
[31] LANDY M, FREIBERGER A.Studies of ice adhesion: I. Adhesion of ice to plastics[J]. Journal of colloid and interface science, 1967, 25(2): 231-244.
[32] MATSUMOTO K, KOBAYASHI T.Fundamental study on adhesion of ice to cooling solid surface[J]. International journal of refrigeration, 2007, 30(5): 851-860.
[33] MATSUMOTO K, MOROHOSHI M, TERAOKA Y.Fundamental study of adhesion of ice to cooling solid surface(discussion on influence of copper oxide layer on ice adhesion force)[J]. International journal of refrigeration, 2009, 32(6): 1336-1342.
[34] MURASE H, NANISHI K, KOGURE H, et al.Interactions between heterogeneous surfaces of polymers and water[J]. Journal of applied polymer science, 1994, 54(13): 2051-2062.
[35] BEEMER D L, WANG W, KOTA A K.Durable gels with ultra-low adhesion to ice[J]. Journal of materials chemistry a, 2016, 4(47), 18253-18258.
[36] FILLION R M, RIAHI A R, EDRISY A.Design factors for reducing ice adhesion[J]. Journal of adhesion science and technology, 2017, 31(21), 2271-2284.
[37] COHEN N, DOTAN A, DODIUK H, et al.Thermomechanical mechanisms of reducing ice adhesion on superhydrophobic surfaces[J]. Langmuir, 2016, 32(37): 9664-9675.
[38] LING E J Y, UONG V, RENAULT-CRISPO J-S, et al. Reducing ice adhesion on nonsmooth metallic surfaces: wettability and topography effects[J]. ACS applied materials & interfaces, 2016, 8(13): 8789-8800.
[39] CHEN T K,CONG Q,LI Y, et al.Utilizing swelling force to decrease the ice adhesion strength[J]. Cold regions science and technology, 2018, 146: 122-126.
[40] RNNEBERG S, ZHUO Y, LAFORTE C, et al.Interlaboratory study of ice adhesion using different techniques[J]. Coatings, 2019, 9(10): 678.
[41] CHEN T K, JIN J F, QI Y C, et al.Disturbing stability of interface by adopting phase-change temperature gradient to reduce ice adhesion strength[J]. Cold regions science and technology, 2019, 158: 69-75.
[42] DOU R M, CHEN J, ZHANG Y F, et al.Anti-icing coating with an aqueous lubricating layer[J]. ACS applied materials & interfaces, 2014, 6(10): 6998-7003.
[43] WANG C, GUPTA M C, YEONG Y H, et al.Factors affecting the adhesion of ice to polymer substrates[J]. Journal of applied polymer science, 2017, 135(24): 45734.
[44] DRUEZ J, PHAN C L, LAFORTE J L, et al.The Adhesion of Glaze and Rime on Aluminium Electrical Conductors[J]. Transactions-Canadian Society for Mechanical Engineering, 1978, 5(4): 215-220.
[45] PHAN C L, MCCOMBER P, MANSIAUX A.Adhesion of rime and glaze on conductors protected by various materials[J]. Transactions-Canadian Society for Mechanical Engineering, 1976, 4(4): 204-208.
[46] DRUEZ J, NGUYEN D D, LAVOIE Y.Mechanical properties of atmospheric ice[J]. Cold regions science and technology, 1986, 13(1): 67-74.
[47] MATSUMOTO K, DAIKOKU Y.Fundamental study on adhesion of ice to solid surface: discussion on coupling of nano-scale field with macro-scale field[J]. International journal of refrigeration, 2009, 32(3): 444-453.
[48] PITTENGER B, COOK D J, SLAUGHTERBECK R C, et al.Investigation of ice-solid interfaces by force microscopy: plastic flow and adhesive forces[J]. Journal of vacuum science & technology A, 1998, 16(3): 1832-1837.
[49] NGUYEN V-H, NGUYEN B D, PHAM H T, et al.Anti-icing performance on aluminum surfaces and proposed model for freezing time calculation[J]. Scientific reports, 2021, 11(1): 3641.
[50] MCDONALD B, PATEL P, ZHAO B X, et al.Droplet freezing and ice adhesion strength measurement on super-cooled hydrophobic surfaces[J]. Journal of adhesion, 2015, 93(5): 375-388.
[51] GUO Z Y, PENG B, LIU Y F, et al.Extremely ice-detached array of pine needle-inspired concave-cone pillars[J]. Advanced materials interfaces, 2019, 7(2): 1901714.
[52] KRAJ A G, BIBEAU E L.Measurement method and results of ice adhesion force on the curved surface of a wind turbine blade[J]. Renewable energy, 2010, 35(4): 741-746.
[53] MENINI R, GHALMI Z, FARZANEH M.Highly resistant icephobic coatings on aluminum alloys[J]. Cold regions science & technology, 2011, 65(1): 65-69.
[54] GUERIN F, LAFORTE C, FARINAS M I, et al.Analytical model based on experimental data of centrifuge ice adhesion tests with different substrates[J]. Cold regions science & technology, 2016, 121: 93-99.
[55] JANJUA Z A.The influence of freezing and ambient temperature on the adhesion strength of ice[J]. Cold regions science & technology, 2017, 140: 14-19.
[56] JANJU Z A, TURNBULL B, CHOY K L, et al.Performance and durability tests of smart icephobic coatings to reduce ice adhesion[J]. Applied surface science, 2017, 407: 555-564.
[57] MOMEN G, JAFARI R, FARZANEH M.Ice repellency behaviour of superhydrophobic surfaces: effects of atmospheric icing conditions and surface roughness[J]. Applied surface science, 2015, 349: 211-218.
[58] RNNEBERG S, LAFORTE C, VOLAT C, et al.The effect of ice type on ice adhesion[J]. AIP advances, 2019, 9(5): 055304.
[59] SALEEMA N, FARZANEH M, PAYNTER R W, et al.Prevention of ice accretion on aluminum surfaces by enhancing their hydrophobic properties[J]. Journal of adhesion science and technology, 2011, 25(1-3): 27-40.
[60] MENINI R, FARZANEH M.Elaboration of Al₂O₃/PTFE icephobic coatings for protecting aluminum surfaces[J]. Surface and coatings technology, 2009, 203(14): 1941-1946.
[61] FORTIN G, PERRON J.Spinning rotor blade tests in icing wind tunnel[C]//1st AIAA Atmospheric and space Environments conference, San Antonic, USA, 2009.
[62] KNUTH T D.Ice adhesion strength modeling based on surface morphology variations[D]. Pennsylvania: The Pennsylvania State University, 2015.
[63] TARQUINI S, ANTONINI C, AMIRFAZLI A, et al.Investigation of ice shedding properties of superhydrophobic coatings on helicopter blades[J]. Cold regions science and technology, 2014, 100: 50-58.
[64] SOLTIS J, PALACIOS J, EDEN T, et al.Evaluation of ice-adhesion strength on erosion-resistant materials[C]//AIAA/journal, 2015, 53(7): 1825-1835.
[65] 丁金波. 结冰表面冻粘特性的试验研究[D]. 上海: 上海交通大学, 2012.
DING J B.Experimental research on icing surface freezing adhesive characteristic[D]. Shanghai: Shanghai Jiao Tong University, 2012.
[66] JELLINEK G H H. The influence of imperfections on the strength of Ice[J]. Proceedings of the Physical Society, 1958, 71(5): 797-814.
[67] PETRENKO V F, PENG S.Reduction of ice adhesion to metal by using self-assembling monolayers(SAMs)[J]. Canadian journal of physics, 2003, 81(1): 387-393.
[68] LAFORTE C.How a solid coating can reduce the adhesion[C]//Proceedings of the International Workshop on Atmospheric Icing of Structures, Brno, Czech, 2002.
[69] ARCHER P, GUPTA V.Measurement and control of ice adhesion to aluminum 6061 alloy[J]. Journal of the mechanics & physics of solids, 1998, 46(10): 1745-1771.
[70] CHU M C, SCAVUZZO R J.Adhesive shear strength of impact ice[J]. AIAA journal, 1991, 29(11): 1921-1926.
[71] 沈贺. 风力机叶片翼型表面结冰粘结强度分析与试验研究[D]. 哈尔滨: 东北农业大学, 2022.
SHEN H.Analytical and experimental researches on the airfoil surface adhesion strength of ice for wind turbine blade[D]. Harbin: Northeast Agricultural University, 2022.